Coconut Treacle vs Kithul Treacle: What’s the Difference?

Order curd in Sri Lanka and you will be asked a question: treacle? Say yes, and the next question is which one. Coconut or kithul?

Coconut treacle and kithul treacle are both syrups boiled down from the sap of tapped palm blossoms, but from two different palms. Coconut treacle comes from the coconut palm and is the everyday treacle of Sri Lankan homes. Kithul treacle comes from the kithul, or fishtail, palm; it is rarer, deeper in taste, valued in Ayurveda and priced to match. This guide explains how each is made, how they taste, what they are called around the world, and which to reach for.

What is treacle in Sri Lanka?

In Britain, treacle is a by-product of refining cane sugar. In Sri Lanka it means something quite different: a syrup made from the sap of tapped palm blossoms, usually coconut or kithul. It is poured over curd, cooked into sweets and stirred into tea.

Coconut treacle: Sri Lanka’s everyday treacle

Coconut treacle is known as pol pani in Sinhala and thengai paagu (தேங்காய் பாகு) in Tamil. Outside Sri Lanka it is usually sold as coconut syrup, coconut nectar or coconut blossom nectar.

Most of it comes from Sri Lanka’s Coconut Triangle, the districts of Kurunegala, Puttalam and Chilaw. Tappers climb the palms and cut the unopened flower bud; the sweet sap that drips out, called thelijja, is collected and boiled down. It takes six to eight bottles of sap to make one bottle of treacle.

Coconut treacle is caramel-rich, with subtle coconutty richness. It is the treacle most Sri Lankan homes reach for: more affordable than kithul, and the one cooked with grated coconut into pani pol, the filling for lavariya.

Kithul treacle: the rarer treacle

Kithul treacle comes from the kithul or fishtail palm (Caryota urens), a tall palm of Sri Lanka’s forests and home gardens. Tapping kithul is a craft of its own: in 2025 UNESCO inscribed Kithul Madeema / Kithul Kapeema on its Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity.

Kithul treacle is deeper and earthier than coconut treacle, often described as date-like. It is valued in Ayurveda, and it costs more.

Coconut treacle vs kithul treacle at a glance

Coconut treacleKithul treacle
PalmCoconut (Cocos nucifera)Kithul, the fishtail palm (Caryota urens)
Local namesPol pani (Sinhala), thengai paagu (Tamil)Kithul pani
Also sold asCoconut syrup, coconut nectar, coconut blossom nectarKithul syrup, kithul honey
TasteCaramel-rich, subtle coconutty richnessDeep, earthy, often described as date-like
Traditional roleThe everyday treacle: curd, pani pol, sweetsValued in Ayurveda; the rarer treacle
PriceMore affordableHigher

Is coconut treacle low GI?

Yes. A 2024 Sri Lankan study measured coconut treacle at GI 53.6 in 30 healthy adults, in the low band (55 or less). A Thai study of organic coconut flower syrup found GI 51. Table sugar is around 65. Treacle is still sugar, about two-thirds sugar by weight, so enjoy it as part of a balanced diet.

Coconut treacle vs maple syrup, honey, agave and date syrup

Coconut treacle sits in a family of natural liquid sweeteners. Here is how it compares with the ones you are most likely to have in the cupboard.

Comes fromGlycemic index (GI)Taste
Coconut treacleCoconut flower sap, Sri Lanka53.6, lowCaramel-rich, subtle coconutty richness
Kithul treacleKithul (fishtail) palm sap, Sri LankaNo published human GI study we could verifyDeep, earthy, date-like
Maple syrupMaple tree sap, Canada and the US54, lowWoody, caramel
HoneyBees, from flower nectar50–65, varies by typeFloral; varies by flower
Agave syrupAgave plant, MexicoLow, because it is mostly fructoseNeutral, very sweet
Date syrupDates55 in one study, lowRich, fruity, caramelised
Table sugarSugar cane or beet, refinedabout 65, mediumPlain sweet

Two things to keep in mind. GI values vary with the product and how it is made, so treat them as a guide rather than a guarantee. And a low GI is not the whole story: agave scores low because it is mostly fructose, which the body handles differently. All of these are still sugars, so enjoy them in sensible amounts.

Where coconut treacle stands out is in the kitchen. It pours like maple syrup and brings a caramel depth that honey and agave do not.

Which treacle should you use?

  • Curd and treacle: either. Coconut for an everyday bowl, kithul for a treat.
  • Pani pol and lavariya: coconut treacle.
  • Pancakes, porridge, baking and coffee: coconut treacle, used like maple syrup or honey.
  • When you want the deepest, most traditional flavour: kithul.

Where to buy coconut treacle and kithul treacle

Goodfolks makes both. Goodfolks Organic Coconut Treacle is certified organic (USDA) and lab tested, in a 350 ml glass bottle. Goodfolks Premium Kithul Treacle is the deeper, rarer choice. Both are sold on JOYUS, our online store, with island-wide delivery and international shipping. Read more on our coconut treacle page, or find Goodfolks at our stockists across Sri Lanka.

Sources

  1. Litha et al. (2024), Sri Lankan Journal of Applied Sciences 3(1): 50–55 — coconut treacle GI 53.6
  2. Leelayuwat et al. (2018), Asia-Pacific Journal of Science and Technology 23(4) — organic coconut flower syrup GI 51
  3. Sugar Australia — sugar GI 65
  4. Sunday Observer (2021), A Treacle Tale: Coconut Treacle
  5. Wikipedia — List of Sri Lankan sweets and desserts
  6. Wikipedia — Caryota urens
  7. UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage — Kithul Madeema / Kithul Kapeema (inscribed 2025)
  8. Glycemic Index Foundation, University of Sydney — Q&A with Jennie Brand-Miller (maple syrup GI 54)
  9. Catherine Saxelby, Foodwatch — Are syrups better for you than sugar? (honey GI 50–65; agave mostly fructose)
  10. Foods (2023) 12(6): 1268 — date syrup GI 55
Cart

No products in the cart.

Create your account